Estimated reading time: 7 minutes
Background checks affect millions of employment and housing decisions every year. Whether applying for a job, renting an apartment, qualifying for federal housing assistance, or seeking professional licensing, these reports often play a decisive role. Yet few people fully understand how background check data can be used in employment or housing decisions—or how to respond when inaccurate, outdated, or misleading information interferes with opportunities.
This guide explains how background checks work, what employers and landlords are allowed to consider, the restrictions placed on them by federal and state laws, and how you can protect yourself from misuse of your personal information.
What Background Checks Include and How They Are Generated
Background checks draw information from a combination of public sources, consumer reporting agencies (CRAs), data brokers, and proprietary databases.
Typical components of a background check include:
- Identity verification
- Address history
- Credit history (housing only, unless position is financial)
- Criminal records
- Civil court records
- Eviction history
- Sex offender registry results
- Employment verification
- Education verification
Depending on the background screening service used, checks may also include:
- Driving records
- Professional licenses
- Social media screening
- Reference checks
Each data category can influence employment or housing decisions differently, and restrictions apply depending on federal guidelines such as the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) and Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) rules.
How Background Check Data Can Be Used in Employment Decisions
Employers in the United States rely heavily on background checks to assess a candidate’s suitability for a role. However, they must comply with the FCRA, anti-discrimination laws, and state-level restrictions.
What Employers Are Allowed to Consider
Employers may consider:
- Verified identity
- Confirmed employment history
- Education credentials
- Criminal history (with limitations)
- Driving record (for roles involving vehicles)
- Licenses required for the position
They may evaluate information based on:
Employers must consider:
- The nature of the job
- The nature of the offense
- The time passed since the offense
For example:
- A DUI conviction may be relevant to a driving role.
- A theft conviction may be relevant to a financial role.
- A decades-old nonviolent misdemeanor may not be relevant to most positions.
What Employers Cannot Legally Use
- Arrest records without conviction, in many states
- Bankruptcy history (protected under federal law)
- Medical history
- Genetic information
- Disability status
- Military records outside permitted scope
Additionally, employers cannot use background checks to discriminate based on protected categories under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act.
How Background Check Data Can Be Used in Housing Decisions
Landlords, property managers, and housing authorities use screening reports to evaluate rental applicants.
What Housing Providers Are Allowed to Consider
- Creditworthiness
- Eviction history
- Criminal convictions
- Income verification
- References
What Housing Providers Cannot Legally Consider
Under the Fair Housing Act (FHA), providers may not make decisions based on:
- Race
- Religion
- National origin
- Sex
- Disability
- Familial status
In 2016, HUD issued guidance stating that blanket bans on criminal history may constitute discrimination due to disparate impact. Landlords must instead evaluate:
- Recency of conviction
- Severity
- Relevance to property safety
How the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) Protects You
The FCRA sets strict rules for how background check data is collected and used in employment or housing decisions.
Key protections include:
1. Right to Consent
An employer or landlord must obtain your written permission before ordering a background check.
2. Right to Disclosure
If a decision will be made based on your background check, you have the right to receive:
- A copy of the report
- A summary of your rights
3. Right to Dispute Inaccurate Information
You may challenge:
- Incorrect criminal records
- Expunged or sealed records that appear
- Wrong addresses
- Mistaken identity
- Mixed files
- Duplicate entries
CRAs generally have 30 days to investigate disputes.
4. Right to Pre-Adverse and Adverse Action Notices (Employment Only)
If an employer plans to deny employment based on your background check, they must:
- Provide a pre-adverse action notice
- Allow you time to respond
- Issue a final adverse action notice only after review
The Role of State Laws in Employment and Housing Background Checks
Several states have passed additional protections beyond federal law.
“Ban the Box” Laws
Many states prohibit employers from asking about criminal history until late in the hiring process.
Salary History Bans
Certain states restrict employers from using past compensation data.
Criminal Record Reporting Limits
Examples:
- California: prohibits reporting convictions older than seven years.
- New York: requires individualized assessments and rehabilitation consideration.
- Illinois: prohibits discrimination based on conviction history unless job-related.
Housing-Specific State Laws
Some states prohibit using:
- Eviction records older than seven years
- Arrest-only records
- Certain dismissed criminal charges
How Inaccurate Background Checks Lead to Wrongful Denials
Errors in background checks are common and can drastically affect employment and housing opportunities.
Common Errors Include:
- Mixed profiles (information from someone with a similar name)
- Outdated criminal records
- Misreported eviction filings
- Incorrect or incomplete case dispositions
- Identity theft impacts
Real-World Consequences
- Job offer rescinded
- Apartment application denied
- Security clearance delayed
- Professional license suspension
These issues highlight the importance of being proactive about reviewing and correcting your background information.
How To Check Your Own Background Before an Employer or Landlord Does
Performing a self-check helps you identify issues early.
Recommended approach:
1. Request your reports from major CRAs
- Experian
- Equifax
- TransUnion
2. Request criminal record checks from your county courthouse
3. Search your information on public record aggregators
4. Review your credit report annually
The FTC allows free access at:
https://www.annualcreditreport.com
5. Search eviction records in state court databases
Protecting Your Personal Information Online
Background check companies often use publicly available data that originates from:
- Data brokers
- People search engines
- Social media
- Public records
- Court systems
The broader your online footprint, the more information appears in these reports.
How Remove Online Information Helps Limit Background Check Exposure
Background check companies rely heavily on data brokers, which scrape and resell personal information. Removing your personal data from these sources significantly reduces what appears in background screening results.
Remove Online Information provides:
- Comprehensive data broker removal
- Ongoing monitoring
- Suppression of personal details
- Removal of outdated or inaccurate information
- Support for identity theft victims
- Customized privacy plans
By eliminating your data from public and private databases, you reduce the risk of:
- Misidentification
- Duplicated records
- Stale information affecting your opportunities
Visit:
👉 https://removeonlineinformation.com
to begin safeguarding your data today.
How Employers and Housing Providers Must Handle Criminal History
H2: EEOC Guidance for Employers
Employers must consider:
- Age of conviction
- Relevance to job duties
- Evidence of rehabilitation
Blanket bans on criminal convictions are prohibited.
HUD Guidelines for Housing Providers
Housing authorities must:
- Avoid discriminatory criminal history policies
- Prohibit blanket bans
- Use individualized assessments
- Consider mitigating factors
How Background Checks Intersect with Privacy Rights
Growing concerns about misuse of personal data have resulted in new privacy laws.
H2: California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA)
Gives consumers the right to:
- Know what data is collected
- Request deletion
- Opt out of data sale
Reference:
https://oag.ca.gov/privacy/ccpa
Fair Housing Act (FHA)
Protects renters from discriminatory screening.
Title VII of the Civil Rights Act
Protects job applicants from discriminatory hiring based on background data.
How To Dispute and Fix Errors on Background Checks
If inaccurate information appears:
Step-by-Step Process
- Request a copy of your report.
- Identify the incorrect items.
- Submit a dispute in writing to the CRA.
- Attach court documents or evidence.
- Wait up to 30 days for investigation.
- Request correction notices be sent to anyone who received the inaccurate report.
Advanced Tips to Protect Your Background Information
Freeze your credit
This prevents fraudulent accounts.
Opt out of data brokers
This reduces exposure in screening reports.
Monitor court records for identity theft
Keep contact details consistent
Sample Template for Disputing Background Check Errors
To Whom It May Concern,
I am writing to dispute inaccurate information that appears in my background check report. The item(s) I am disputing are incorrect and do not pertain to me.
Item(s) disputed:
[List items]
Supporting documents are attached.
Please investigate this matter and correct the inaccuracies as required under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA).
Sincerely,
[Your Name]
FAQ: How Background Check Data Is Used in Employment and Housing Decisions
Yes, but only when the information is accurate, job-related, and compliant with FCRA and EEOC guidelines.
Yes, though state rules limit the age of eviction data that may be used.
Varies by state. FCRA allows reporting indefinitely unless state law restricts it (e.g., seven-year limit in CA).
Yes—credit checks are common for rental applications.
Yes. Most screening databases pull preliminary identity data from brokers.
MLA Citations
Federal Trade Commission. Summary of Rights Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act. FTC.gov, 2024.
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. Enforcement Guidance on the Consideration of Arrest and Conviction Records. EEOC.gov, 2024.
U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. Guidance on Application of Fair Housing Act Standards to the Use of Criminal Records. HUD.gov, 2016.
California Office of the Attorney General. California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA). OAG.ca.gov, 2024.
United States Department of Justice. Fair Housing Act Overview. Justice.gov, 2024.
Related Contents: